Our Stores

    Shop Around Newfane and Olcott

    There’s nothing like spending a sunny Saturday morning strolling the boardwalk and browsing collections of handmade gifts and snacks. Newfane and Olcott Beach, home to businesses both new and old, truly fits the mold of Smalltown, USA. Whether it’s pizza or ice cream, handcrafted artisan jewelry, or even specialty dog treats, there’s really something for every shopper on Main Street and neighboring hamlets and towns like Burt and Appleton. Plus, Olcott is home to one of the world’s most famous and delicious popcorn stands: Bye’s Popcorn. Like every shop in Newfane and Olcott, it’s a must-visit.

    Bye’s Popcorn

    The freshest, best-tasting popcorn in Western New York, if not the world. Grab a warm bag on your way in or out as it’s located on Lockport-Olcott Road.

    Encore Consignments

    Main Street’s women’s and children’s consignment shop is heaven for bargain hunters.

    Gifts from the Village

    Perfect for holiday shopping as you’ll find a gift for everyone on your shopping list, conveniently located on Hess Road.

    Gordie Harper’s Bazaar

    They say life’s too short for average food and we couldn’t agree more. Stop in for baked goods and leave with imports, antiques and much more on Lockport-Olcott Road.

    Graydog Toys & Treats

    Your furry friends deserve the best. Pick up a bag of gourmet snacks for your pet as a souvenir on McClew Road.

    Heimiller Greenhouse

    Located on Ewings Road, the family owned and operated greenhouse is a gardener’s paradise with plants and flowers all locally grown.

    Images of the Past

    Take a walk down memory lane, recapture old memories and make new ones at this shopping destination on Ontario Street.

    Lakeview Village Shoppes

    A boardwalk with cute shops that offer unique gifts, handmade jewelry and delectable treats. Open weekend from noon to 6 p.m. in May, Sept., and Oct. Memorial Day to Labor Day, Sunday to Thursday from noon to 6 p.m., Friday and Saturday from noon to 8 p.m.

    • Abby Joe’s Unique Boutique
    • Cameron’s Lakeside Ice Cream
    • Emma’s Tiques & Treasures
    • Gift Box at the Beach
    • KM Eats
    • KM Treats
    • Nature’s Child
    • Oak Ridge Designs
    • SeaHag
    • Up the Lake
    • VacantiArts
    Page by Page Used Books

    Snuggle up with a page-turner found at our affordable used book store on Lockport-Olcott Road.

    Shoppe on Main

    Newfane’s finest gallery of art from local artists, handmade jewelry, pottery, glassware and more right on Main Street.

    Listen below for more on Main Street in Newfane

    St. Andrew’s Community Store

    Feeling thrifty? Find hidden gems and diamonds in the rough at the Community Store on Main Street.

    Red House Music

    Need your guitar tuned? How about lessons to go with that new drum kit? Red House Music on Main Street in Newfane has what you need!