Enjoy Your Home Away from Home

Our broad selection of accommodations means that your stay is tailored to best fit your interests. Whether you’re a fisherman, a family, or a couple, you’ll be warmly welcomed into our cozy cottages, warm bed and breakfasts, charming inns and delightful motels. Amenities abound at the family-owned Brookins Inn. Families can reunite for a summer vacation at the Beachfront Vacation Cottages. Worldly fishermen can rest their eyes in our Captain’s Corner Cottages.

Plan Your Stay in the Perfect Vacation Rental

Cottages

  • Beachfront Vacation Cottages

    5785 Beach Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 304-9797

    Website

  • Captain’s Corner Cottages

    1581 Franklin Street
     Olcott, NY 14126

    5798 West Main Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 628-4890

    Website

  • Dee’s Bungalow

    1568 Van Buren Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 433-8139

    Website

  • McDonough’s

    5867 Ontario Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-7665

  • Ontario Shores Rentals

    1554 Van Buren Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-9364

    Website

  • Pete’s Place Guest House

    5780 West Main Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-0713

  • Convenience Cottages

    The Albright House
     5806 West Main Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 870-6244

    Website

  • Convenience Cottages

    The Franklin House
     5811 West Main Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 870-6244

    Website

  • Convenience Cottages

    The G.H. Fletcher House
     5802 West Main Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 870-6244

    Website

  • Convenience Cottages

    The Harbor House
     1578 Water Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 870-6244

    Website

  • Convenience Cottages

    The Tenbrook
     5813 West Main Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 870-6244

    Website

  • Johnson Properties

    Creekside Cottage
     1676 Lockport-Olcott Road
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-9032

    Website

  • Johnson Properties

    Northern Comfort I
     5796 Saxton Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-9032

    Website

  • Johnson Properties

    Northern Comfort II
     5800 Saxton Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-9032

    Website

  • The Hardt House

    1582 Clinton Street
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (717) 331-2170

    Website

  • Bev's Lake House

    5559 Lockwood Heights
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 807-6631

    Website

Inns & Suites

  • Brookins Inns & Suites

    2697 Maple Avenue
     Newfane, NY 14108
     (716) 807-6631

    Website

  • The Fly Inn Lodge

    1800 West Creek Road
     Burt, NY 14028
     (716) 778-6700
     (855) 347-969

    Website

  • Abe's on Main

    2728 Main St.
     Newfane, NY 14108
     (716) 778-9206

    email

  • Old Olcott Beach Firestation Guestrooms & Suites

    1573 Lockport St.
     Olcott, NY 14126
     (716) 778-4443

    Website

Motels

  • Harbor Resort Motel & Campground

    1622 Lockport-Olcott Road
    Olcott, NY 14126
    (716) 778-8747
    (716) 550-1021


  • Lake Ontario Motel

    3330 Lockport-Olcott Road
    Newfane, NY 14108
    (716) 778-5004

    Website

  • Lighthouse Motel

    1563 Jackson Street
    Olcott, NY 14126
    (716) 778-7270

Bed & Breakfasts

  • Bayside Guest House

    1572 Lockport-Olcott Road
    Olcott, NY 14126
    (716) 778-7767

  • Cooke’s Creekview B&B

    Lockport-Olcott Road
    Newfane, NY 14108
    (716) 534-0920

  • Hendrick’s House

    2666 Main Street
    Newfane, NY 14108
    (716) 778-7342

    Website